High-pitched noise coming from computer

08
2014-07
  • Mauricio Scheffer

    Computer is ~3 years old. For the last 2 years, on hot days only (28C (82F) or more) it makes a high-pitched, quite loud, and very annoying noise. This noise comes in short bursts (up to 3 seconds long) and the occurrence frequency is unpredictable.

    I've recorded a sample: http://www.box.net/shared/lqd3zc0ja4

    The noise doesn't seem to be related to any particular activity, i.e. it occurs when the computer is idle, with and without high I/O activity, with and without high CPU usage.

    I'm also sure it's not the PSU, as I've changed it and it's still screeching.

    EDIT: it's definitely not a digital beep, it's an analog whine.

    There is no crashing or freezing or anything abnormal when it screeches like this but it's quite annoying during summer. I've read (here, here) that it can be some electronic component in the motherboard gone bad. Is there any way to find which one is it? (carefully listening doesn't work, I've tried!) Is it even worth it? Is there any way to be relatively sure it's the motherboard and not the CPU or RAM or something else?

    EDIT: I've now installed SpeedFan to see what's the temperature threshold where it starts making noise. Will update on the next hot day :)

  • Answers
  • Iszi

    If it's not something emitting from an actual built-in speaker on the motherboard or another part, I'd look next to moving parts. The only part that moves fast enough to sustain a noise of that high frequency would be your hard drive. Try running the following (Windows) command:

    CHKDSK /R
    

    This should scan for bad sectors on the hard drive, and attempt to recover information if any are found. If the scan does find bad sectors (a report is generated when the scan is completed) then this is probably your problem. Shut down the system until you've found a replacement drive.

    Other than the hard drive, I don't know what might specifically cause that sort of noise. If it is indeed in one of the non-moving parts of your system, the only solution may be to try listening more carefully or swap out parts until the noise stops.

  • Gilles

    From the recording I can't tell whether it's more of a beep or more of a whine. Could you record a motherboard beep for comparison? Also a longer recording could help (is that really a second frequency at the end?).

    If it's a beep, it could be your motherboard telling you something, or it could be a defect in the speaker. Try unplugging the speaker (in typical PCs there's a wire you can unplug somewhere; if you have the manual for your motherboard the right wire should be easy to find).

    Otherwise it's probably a particularly loud electronics whine (I think it's too high-pitched to come from a fan, and too irregular to come from a disk). This can indeed happen to aging electronic components.

    Did you open the case? This is pretty much necessary to get any clue as to the origin of the noise by ear. You might have some luck gently pressing your finger in some places and seeing if the noise changes. Mind your fingers though: don't touch any chip as they're usually burning hot, don't touch exposed conductors (you won't get electrocuted on a motherboard but your finger residues could cause a short), and don't apply so much mechanical pressure that you break something. Try gently pressing on edges of the motherboard, any extension board, RAM sticks...

  • dev1

    It could be an alarm of some sort on your motherboard. Most motherboards have an audible alarms to indicate high temperature within the CPU. Check with the mobo manufacturer if it comes with a software utility.


  • Related Question

    How to judge noise level when configuring a computer on dell.com or hp.com
  • BluePants

    The last desktop I bought from Dell (Dimension XPS) was much noisier than I would have liked. I am planning on buying a new desktop soon and would like to consider noise level when configuring a system. I did not find much relevant info on dell.com.

    Is there a way to judge how much noise a particular configuration will make when configuring a system on dell.com or hp.com? I'd be even OK with a way to simply compare various configurations to each other (this config is more loud) if absolute numbers are hard to obtain. I do not need the system to be super silent. I just don't want to be surprised when I plug it in.

    Also, are particular product lines known to be more quiet than others (dell stuido, xps, various models of hp Pavilion)? I need something with an i7 processor and at least 8GB of memory. Everything else is not super important.


  • Related Answers
  • hyperslug

    I just bought a Dell Studio XPS, core i7 (2 weeks ago, maybe) and I was surprised by how quiet it was. It does roar to life when you first turn it on, but it quickly subsides to below average levels. The fan does ramp up a little in response to increased processing levels, but the only thing I've really pushed it with was Google Earth.

    In general, if you want assurances for noise level, you'll have to DIY, and for that I recommend Silent PC Review. You could mod an OEM system by buying your own PSU, upgrading your heatsink, or pasting on antivibrational dampening foam (like Acoustipack), but you're better off building from scratch.

  • Mike M

    in general, going with a SATA hard drive (as opposed to the older IDE) will reduce noice. I imagine most if not all of the computers come w/ SATA default by now.

    Other than that a fan on the graphics card would generate more noise and may not be present on all systems.

    If you get one and decide its to noisy, look into replacing your heatsink fan with a higher quality one.

  • Troggy

    Dell does a decent job when it comes to noise with most of thier pc's. Obviously, the server grade stuff is going to be noisy, but almost all their consumer products I have experienced have been rather quiet. The slim desktops might be a little different story with the reduced size and airflow, but I haven't ran into too many noisy newer dell's. The high performance gaming ones I am sure will rev up a bit if you get them loaded down, but for normal use, most of their stuff should be decent. This is just my experience though.

    That would be a great question to ask one of the higher level support technitions through dell and see if you can get official numbers or information. I suggest you call them and ask.