hard drive - What should I look for to have a silent external harddrive

08
2014-07
  • user1987442

    I want a HD as a home media-server, it will always be on. Most of the time it will not be used, and it should be very silent and not to warm when not used.

    Should be Regularly priced powered 2-3T external USB drive.

    What should I look for to have that? Will drives usually stop spinning when not used, bringing the temperature down to a point where the fan will stop working?

  • Answers
  • Hennes

    Will drives usually stop spinning when not used,

    Drives can stop spinning when they are not used.

    How soon that happens depends on the configuration of both the drive and the OS. The OS because it can send the drive a command to spin down. Or on the drive since modern SATA drives have the capability to do this on their own.

    You did mention an OS, but if you run a unix (e.g. a BSD or a Linux distribution) then look at hdparm. This is a persistent setting on the drive. (In other words: you only have to set it once).

    Note that regular drive access (such as flushing log files or writing to the event log) will reset this timer. So it works best if you do not use the drive to host the OS.

    This can best be combined with a small SSD (say 40GB-ish) which will not spin nor make noise. The SSD then holds the OS. The large spinning disk the data.

    and the heat then so low that the fan will not be working?

    The heat from drives usually is not a problem unless you run some old 15K RPM high performance drives. For a HTPC you would use a low RPM green drive. These are notably slower when doing random access (e.g. when using an OS or when running programs), but their sequential read/write speed is more than enough for movies, music etc.


    As for the silent part of a drive: Get a low RPM drive. Usually those are branded as 'green'.


    Not asked but: Why an external drive?

    Putting the storage drive inside the HTPC would have less clutter and would be faster. (Navtive SATA access rather than using an extra SATA to USB part, an extra case and an extra power supply).

  • BillR

    Issue: "home media server" (original question) versus "normally be connected to a router" (clarifying comment).

    Sounds like you are really describing network accessible storage to be used primarily for storing movies, etc. Some home gateway routers include a USB port for that purpose but most don't.

    Almost any "green" external USB drive should work well when attached to an APPROPRIATE router provided you are just using it for one TV/display at a time. Most drives are packaged as external drives without a fan at all or you can build your own by pairing a disk drive and enclosure. Metal cases usually cost a little more but dissipate heat better (simple physics provided the drive is tightly coupled thermally to the case). Make sure the enclosure has plenty of circulating air (i.e., not in a closed cabinet nor tucked behind books in a bookshelf nor in the back of a closet shelf behind winter hats and scarves) and isn't on top of/next to a heat source (i.e., not under/over a heating vent nor on top of a stereo), nor flat on the carpet under under a powerstrip and tangle of cords. For your purposes opt for a separate power supply ("brick") instead of an power supply integrated in the case. A backup fan in the enclosure may not run at all but is nice to have just in case (e.g., for an all day movie marathon or when the AC breaks).

    If you want to connect the drive directly to your router/network, you probably want a NAS device instead that you can attach to the WAN port of the router. Again, almost any "green" hard disk .... (but most NAS enclosures do have fans since most are designed for commercial use with high speed often busy drives).

    One additional consideration: will your network and drive provide the necessary bandwidth for your purpose. The drive or network might not support simultaneously playing movies on multiple devices.


  • Related Question

    Brand new Mac Pro tower fan suddenly runs full-tilt
  • Caffeine Coma

    My Quad-Core Mac Pro tower is two days old. Initially, I was impressed with how quiet it was compared to my older Macbook Pro. Then on day two, for some reason it started running very loudly. It's not just a "little" loud- my wife walked into the room and asked what the noise was.

    At first I thought this was just because I was hitting the CPU a bit (importing my iPhone library into iLife '09, and running Eclipse). But now that that's done, Activity Monitor shows a virtually idle CPU; there's nothing running that ought to be causing this, as far as I can tell.

    I tried powering it off & letting it cool down for a few minutes to no avail; about 10 seconds after powering up, the box gets loud again. I took a look at it with the side cover off, and it seems to be the fan near the top middle, between the power supply and the disk drive.

    It can't be a dust issue, as the machine is only 2 days old (and I peeked inside anyway just to be sure- clean). I did do a software update over the past 24 hours or so, but I can't say that it occurred immediately after that. I also did a migration of my old apps and data from my MBPro, for what it's worth.

    1. Why is it suddenly so loud?
    2. How can I monitor the fan speed and various system temperatures?

    My temps and fan speeds:

    enter image description here

    UPDATE 1:

    Took it to the Apple Store. They took it in the back (where it's presumably quieter) and ran a fan diagnostic; no problems were found. The guy also told me that it was "a little loud", but normal. I don't buy it. It was virtually silent the first 24 hours I was using it. They would not replace/service it in the store (grrr... that's why I went there, as directed by Apple Care) but said I could get a replacement from the online store, as it was just purchased. I think I will try that.

    UPDATE 2:

    Apple is letting me send it back for a replacement. Glad to see so many responses to this question mentioning that the MacPros are usually silent; it's not all just in my head.


  • Related Answers
  • emgee

    I would image the drive and take it back. Sounds like a problem in the fan control hardware and/or firmware. I have a few MacPros at work and they are quiet. The hardware test you're already doing is also a good idea.

  • ridogi

    Is there enough space behind it for air flow?

    Is the case closed when it is powered on (it should be)?

    Have you viewed "All Processes" and not just "My Processes" in activity monitor to make sure a processor isn't pegged?

    Have you run Software Update to make sure you have the latest OS?

    Have you run the Apple Hardware Test?

  • Jon Hadley

    It might be that the fan (or a bearing inside it) is broken, causing the extra noise?

    Or perhaps the temperature sensor is faulty and things the CPU is much hotter than it actually is?

    EDIT: Also, I've heard of faulty power supplies overheating the battery and laptop, might be worth checking too.